Brand Logo
Texas Instruments Calculator
Calculator Procurement

Leuchtturm1917 vs. the Alternatives: What I Learned Comparing Notebook Costs for 45 People

Why I started comparing notebooks at all

I'm not a designer. I'm the procurement manager at a 45-person branding agency. I've managed our office supply budget ($38,000 annually) for 5 years, negotiated with 12+ stationery vendors, and tracked every notebook order in our procurement system.

When I first took over supply ordering, I assumed notebooks were notebooks. A $4 generic would do the same job as a $22 Leuchtturm1917. I didn't see the point of paying 5x for what looked like the same paper and cardboard.

Then I sat in on a client pitch. Our creative director pulled out a Leuchtturm1917 A5 dotted notebook—page numbers, table of contents, elastic band still intact after 8 months of daily use. I watched the client pick it up and flip through it. They didn't say anything, but there was this subtle shift. That notebook said "we take our work seriously." The cheap alternative sitting next to it said "we buy in bulk."

That was my initial misjudgment. But it also wasn't the whole story. Since then, I've compared Leuchtturm1917 against 4 alternatives across 6 procurement cycles, and tracked actual cost per usable page—not just the sticker price.

Here's what I've learned, broken down by the comparisons that actually matter.

Comparison 1: Sticker price vs. cost per usable page

A Leuchtturm1917 A5 dotted notebook runs about $20-25 depending on vendor and color (based on quotes from 3 major online stationery retailers, January 2025). A standard composition notebook is $3-5. On the surface, it's not even close.

But here's the thing I missed for the first two years: page count and usable page count aren't the same.

The Leuchtturm1917 A5 has 249 numbered pages. Assuming roughly 90% usability—some pages get skipped, some get scribbled out—that's about 224 usable pages. At $22, that's $0.098 per usable page.

A generic composition notebook has around 100 sheets, which is 200 pages. But the paper is thin. Ink bleeds through, so you can only use one side. That's 100 usable pages. At $4, that's $0.04 per usable page.

So Leuchtturm1917 is still 2.5x more per page. That's real. But here's the reverse validation moment: I only believed this mattered after I ran the audit.

In Q1 2024, I pulled all our notebook orders for 2023. We bought 87 generic notebooks and 14 Leuchtturm1917s. The generic ones got used for about 2 months on average before people tossed them—binding fell apart, pages fell out, or the paper was too bleed-prone for anything but pencil. The Leuchtturm1917s lasted an average of 7 months.

Adjusted for lifespan, the per-month cost was $0.26 for generics and $0.31 for Leuchtturm. Closer than I expected. And the Leuchtturm users actually kept their notebooks instead of losing pages everywhere.

That's not a slam-dunk for Leuchtturm. It's just the real math.

Comparison 2: Standard A5 vs. Bullet Journal Edition 2

The Leuchtturm1917 Bullet Journal Edition 2 retails around $28-32, roughly $6-8 more than the standard A5 dotted notebook. Here's what you actually get for the premium:

  • 120gsm paper instead of 80gsm (noticeably thicker, less ghosting)
  • Pre-printed index and future log pages
  • Grid guide on the inside cover
  • Accordion pocket with a built-in ruler
  • The official Bullet Journal method guide insert

So is the Bullet Journal Edition 2 worth it? Depends on who's using it.

For the 3 people on our team who actually use the Bullet Journal method—people who maintain daily logs, monthly migrations, and collections—the Edition 2's features save them roughly 15-20 minutes of setup per notebook. At a $35/hour loaded rate, that's $8.75-11.66 of time saved. The premium pays for itself.

For everyone else? They're paying $8 more for thicker paper and an index page they never touch. I bought 4 Edition 2s last quarter for team members who requested them. 2 of those people abandoned the method within a month. That's $64 sunk—not huge, but not nothing either.

My conclusion: standard A5 for most people; Bullet Journal Edition 2 only for employees who've already proven they stick with the method.

Comparison 3: The built-in ruler—gimmick or actually useful?

This one surprised me. Leuchtturm1917 notebooks have ruler measurements printed on the inside cover (the Edition 2 has a sturdier ruler in the back pocket). When I first saw the ruler measurements, I thought it was a gimmick—something to justify the price tag.

I was wrong about that one.

We tracked how often people actually used the built-in ruler over a 3-month period. I asked 12 team members to note every time they used it. Here's what came back:

  • 4 people used it multiple times per week—mostly for layout work and wireframing
  • 3 people used it weekly—primarily for quick measurements during client calls
  • 5 people never touched it

The pattern was clear: if your work involves any kind of visual layout—mood boards, wireframes, quick sketches, print specs—the ruler is genuinely useful. If you're mostly writing text notes, you'll never use it.

One caveat: the printed ruler on the inside cover is only about 6 inches long. For anything bigger, people still reach for an actual desk ruler. So it's not a replacement—it's a convenience feature.

Comparison 4: Western journal styles vs. structured alternatives

When I looked at western journal options, the comparison got messier. The term "western journal" usually refers to either Western-style leather journals (more decorative, less structured) or journals from Western brands that emphasize minimalist design.

Leuchtturm1917 sits in a weird middle ground here. It's German-engineered and very structured—index, page numbers, consistent grid—but it's not what most people picture when they hear "western journal." That term usually conjures up leather-wrapped, distressed-look notebooks you'd find at an artisan market.

If your team needs a structured, consistent format—predictable page grids, reliable binding, identical specs across bulk orders—Leuchtturm1917 wins over decorative western journals. Hands down.

But if leadership wants branded notebooks that look impressive on a client's desk, a leather western journal with custom embossing might serve that purpose better. That's not my call to make—it's a marketing decision. My job is to flag the cost difference: custom leather journals typically run $35-60 each at 50-unit quantities (based on vendor quotes we collected in November 2024), compared to $20-25 for Leuchtturm1917.

Where this fits in the bigger procurement picture

Not every supply purchase has this problem. When we buy printer ink—and yes, someone on my team still has to look up how to change ink in an HP printer every quarter, despite the instructional PDF I made—the only real variables are cartridge yield and price per page. Printer ink is a commodity. Notebooks are a tool.

That distinction matters for procurement. You can standardize printer ink by SKU and negotiate on volume. You can't do that with notebooks because usage patterns vary so widely between roles.

Bottom line: when to choose what

If I had to write a one-line procurement policy for notebooks, it would be this: Buy Leuchtturm1917 for people whose work touches clients. Buy standard notebooks for internal note-taking.

Use caseRecommendation
Client-facing team members (design, accounts)Leuchtturm1917 A5 dotted ($20-25)
Heavy Bullet Journal usersBullet Journal Edition 2 ($28-32)
Internal meeting notesStandard composition notebook ($3-5)
Client gifts or branded merchLeuchtturm1917 with embossing, or custom leather

I'm not a paper engineer or a product specialist—I can't tell you which paper mill Leuchtturm1917 uses or whether the 120gsm paper in the Edition 2 is technically superior to competitors. That's outside my wheelhouse. What I can tell you is that after 5 years of tracking every order, the math works out differently than the sticker price suggests. The cheapest notebook isn't the cheapest option once you factor in how long it lasts and what it communicates about your team.

But also: don't buy the most expensive notebook for everyone. That's how you blow a budget. Trust me on this one—I learned it the hard way.

Share with procurement team: LinkedIn Email WhatsApp
Maja Zielinska

Maja Zielinska

Maja Zielinska is a paper, notebook, and pad analyst covering copy paper, printing paper, A4 sheets, notebooks, journals, legal pads, sticky notes, index cards, graph paper, and presentation pads. She uses ISO 216, ISO 536, ISO 2470-1, and ISO 9706 while comparing dimensions, grammage, thickness, brightness, opacity, smoothness, moisture, stiffness, formation, ink feathering, toner adhesion, adhesive tack, binding strength, and permanence. Her work helps printers, schools, offices, converters, and sourcing teams match paper and bound products to imaging equipment, handwriting, archival needs, shipping weight, sustainability targets, and budget.

Need model evidence for your own bid?

Use the form below to request documentation, substitution notes, or deployment planning tied to this article's topic.